| All FCIAC | All-State First | All-American | ||||
| 1990 | Dave Cochran | Dave Cochran | Dave Cochran | |||
| Dan Hoak | Dan Hoak | Dan Hoak | ||||
| Peter Arnold | Peter Arnold | |||||
| Scott Harrison | Scott Harrison | |||||
| 1991 | Ed Curry | |||||
| Scott Harrison | ||||||
| 1992 | Adam Butterworth | Adam Butterworth | Adam Butterworth | |||
| David Curry | ||||||
| Tyler Hardy | ||||||
| 1993 | David Curry | David Curry | David Curry | |||
| Tyler Hardy | Tyler Hardy | Tyler Hardy | ||||
| 1994 | Tim Jandovitz | |||||
| 1995 | Brandon Hall | |||||
| 1996 | Chip Buzzeo | Chip Buzzeo | Chip Buzzeo | |||
| Don Gerne | Don Gerne | Don Gerne | ||||
| Dave Campbell | Dave Campbell | Craig Schubert | ||||
| Craig Schubert | Craig Schubert | Dave Campbell | ||||
| (CT Player of the Year) | ||||||
| 1997 | Mike Adair | Mike Adair | ||||
| Drew Rowley | Drew Rowley | |||||
| Doug McCann | ||||||
| Mike Liddell - Hon Mention | ||||||
| 1998 | Devin Farrell | Devin Farrell | Doug McCann | |||
| Doug McCann | Doug McCann | |||||
| Brant Gresham - 2nd | ||||||
| Austin Garrison-Hon Mention | ||||||
| Alex Mears - Hon Mention | ||||||
| Geoff Mitchell -Hon Mention | ||||||
| 1999 | Dan Geiger | Dan Geiger | Brant Gresham | |||
| Brant Gresham | Brant Gresham | |||||
| Paul Jepson | ||||||
| Matt Twombly -2nd team | ||||||
| Jordan Ceresa - Hon Mention | ||||||
| Brian DeMichele - Hon Mention | ||||||
| Bill Mountain - Hon Mention | ||||||